Sunday, February 24, 2019

If I Die in a Combat Zone

The novels If I Die in a encounter order and The Things They Carried were both written by Tim OBrien. Tim OBrien is a Vietnam war veteran and all of the novels he wrote atomic number 18 about his quantify in the war. He includes the same characters in the stories, simply changed their names and descriptions. I do not believe that OBrien wrote the books for any political reason. both(prenominal) of the novels have very much in common including the style that it is written, and the stories that are told. There are in any case differences including the order of the stories, and the endings.These similarities and differences are important for the novels because it shows the renewing that different soldiers go through in times of war. The style that OBrien writes in both novels is first person narrative. OBrien tells the story in his point of view, and tells different stories. In If I Die in a battle Zone the stories he tells his whole time in Vietnam. He starts with how he got drafted into the war and his training. He considered leaving the country to go survive in Europe. At the last minute he almost left, but then decided to stay and go to Vietnam.He continues the story in chronological order of the times and monuwork forcetal events that had happened throughout his duty. In The Things They Carried, OBrien told significant stories that were told out of chronological order. The stories told in The Things They Carried were also less biographical and focus more on the men in his platoon. He also jumps stomach and forth between the war and post war, where he talked to the surviving men from his platoon. He tells the stories of the war, and the stories that the men told him. This is one of the differences between the two books.The ways the stories are told are different. Even though both books are told in the office of OBrien, when he is telling the stories in The Things They Carried, we are more charitable to the other characters because it mostly fo cuses on them. In both of the stories, OBrien also uses the same terminology in the books. He uses what I describe as war terminology. He uses words and acronyms. For example he said that they were feel for Charlie. Im not very educated on the Vietnam War so I looked up who Charlie was. Then I realized that Charlie is the Vietnamese army.There were other terms including the different guns and different mine types. Thankfully, OBrien explained those terms. OBrien is consistent with his terms and it makes it easier to read one book after rendering the other because of this consistency. The endings of If I Die in a Combat Zone and The Things They Carried are different. In If I Die in a Combat Zone, the end is OBrien going home from Vietnam. He says that there is no joy in leaving Vietnam. He says that he thought of the friends he gained and the friends he lost. He reminisced what he involveed, and realized that he did not learn a lot.The ending of The Things They Carried is one las t story that focused on OBrien. It was the first time that he had seen a dead organic structure in Vietnam. It then flashes back to his past where his girlfriend had died because of a idea tumor. That was the first time he had seen a dead body. The soldiers say that to forestall a person animated is to always tell memories. But OBrien didnt do that, he just imagined that his girlfriend was still alive and waiting for him. Although collectively I did not like either of Tim OBriens books, but I can say that they are vigorous written.The reason I did not like the books was because of the graphics that were described. I meet that learning about the Vietnam War is important, and the horrific aspects are important to learn also, but I do not agree with describing in compass point about bodies world blown to pieces. Both books have their similarities in being that they are about the Vietnam War, the style of the book, and the stories and their content. Although the differences were big, including the order of the stories, and the perspective of the stories, the books are unaired in content. I believe that these books can be read at the same time with each other.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.